Like many lakeside resorts in New York (see Ontario Beach Park and Onondaga Lake) several factors contributed to its decline. For one, most people could not afford luxury during the Great Depression. Second, the rapid adoption of the automobile by American families, allowed people to skip the train and trolley and drive themselves to the beach. There they would spend the day and then drive back that night, negating the need for hotels. By the late 1930s most tourism institutions at Olcott had disappeared.
Between 1930 and 1933, the carousel took a rest from its travels at Olcott Beach on Lake Ontario, and in 1933 it was sold to an amusement park on Cuba Lake (OliveCrest) in New York's Allegany County, where it remained until the park closed in 1972. The museum (New York State) acquired the carousel from a private collector.
Men knocked at our door at all hours, asking if we had worms or fish eggs to sell, or if we sold boat motor parts. Life became a nightmare. I finally lost it when one of the fishermen ogled my daughter. At fifteen, she looked pretty good in a bathing suit, and she had the.....